The inefficiency of AI in preaching

Cut sermon prep time dramatically. Never stare at a blank page again — instant sermon series ideas by season. Ready to get your Saturday nights back? Did you know 12 hours per week is the average pastors spend on sermon prep and ministry content? With the right AI prompts, that same work can be done in a fraction of the time — without losing your own voice or theological depth. 

Such is Claude’s promise to busy pastors.

You can save $50 and purchase at the special price of only $27, if you sign up today. This offer is valid only today. 

So said my Facebook feed this morning.

Pastor beware. Guard your heart. Guard your flock. Take responsibility. Keep it real. Put in the hours. Labour with love. 

Close your computer, get on your knees, ask God to help you, speak to you, shape you, and reform you. Open your Bible, open your mind, and open your heart. What does it say? What does it mean? How should I respond? What is God saying – not to the congregation – but to you? That’s right, keep it personal, examine yourself, speak to yourself, pray for yourself. Let God have his way with you. Meditate on this passage, look intently into this scripture, don’t forget what it says, but apply it to yourself. 

Preacher, you are not fit to preach unless you have first deeply and personally wrestled with God’s word to you. You do this, don’t you? You consider your own response first. You look for logs before diagnosing specks. You apply the Bible to yourself, pray for God’s strength to repent and renew your faith in the gospel. You must ask God to do his transforming work in yourself.

Then you may apply it to others. Then you can say follow my example, as I follow the example of Christ. You can preach with logos, pathos, and ethos. You can model humility before the word of life. You can urge with patience. You can encourage with hope. You can offer the grace of Christ to the weak and sinful, because you have received that grace and you know it to be liberating. You can preach from your heart. You can teach with your mind. You can persuade with your words. You can point people to Jesus – the Jesus you have met in his word.

As you minister the word of God in your church, make it a labour of love. Work at it. Take the time. Start early. If you’re preaching on Sunday, don’t leave your prep until Saturday. Start on Monday. Better still start the week or weeks before. Give it more time to digest. God’s word was never intended to be fast food. Take it slow, savour the flavours, understand what you are eating. 

If you find it hard, then pray. Ask God for insight, for understanding and wisdom. Of course, discuss it with others, consult commentaries, explore cross-references, even listen to others. But keep it real. Consult with real people, who’ve done real work, who’ve also had to examine their hearts, who’ve borne the burden of love for their congregations, their readers, and their listeners.

Don’t mistake Artificial for authentic. It’s an algorithmic, heartless, soulless, lifeless, unhuman alternative. And don’t mistake Intelligence for insight. AI doesn’t fear the Lord, desire your salvation, or seek your sanctification.

Claude is promising you efficiency. Sign up and you will only have to spend a fraction of the time in the Bible and you will have more time for prayer. Yeah right! Show me the person who makes life hacks so they can spend more time on their knees. God calls people to the ministry of the prayer and the word. Both take effort and effort takes time. Efficiency is no longer efficient if it distracts us from the matters that matter most. 

In 2 Timothy 2:15, the Apostle Paul calls Timothy to Do your best to present yourself to Good as one approved, a worker who has no need to be ashamed, rightly handling the word of truth. And in 1 Timothy 5:17 he writes Let the elders who rule well be considered worthy of double honour, especially those who labour in preaching and teaching.

Preachers are called to be workers, hard workers, handing the word of God without shame or pretence. Don’t look for short cuts. Look for God to transform you as you carefully handle your preparation. Stay committed to labouring in your preaching and teaching, lest all the honour be given to Claude.